Abstract
This paper analyzes the pivotal role of Niccolò Machiavelli in Roberto
Esposito’s philosophical framework and traces the evolution of his
interpretation of Machiavelli’s views on politics. In Esposito’s thought,
Machiavelli serves as an essential counterbalance that corrects the apolitical
and fatalistic tendencies inherent in his theory of biopolitics and restores a
robust concept of political agency through conflictand decision. This paper
demonstrates that Esposito’s early thought begins with an analysis of
Machiavelli’s Discourses on Livy, establishing that political order is the
productive outcome of social conflict. This interpretation is then
philosophically deepened by contrasting two opposing paradigms of modern
politics: the Machiavellian, which institutionalizes conflict, and the
Hobbesian, which neutralizes it. This paper illuminates the process by which
Esposito’s mature thought, influenced by Claude Lefort, reinterprets
Machiavelli as the origin of “instituent thought” (pensiero istituente). Here,
politics is defined not as a singular act of foundation (Antonio Negri) or
destitution (Giorgio Agamben), but as the dynamic process of giving durable
form to conflict. This paper argues that Esposito’s Machiavelli offers a
contemporary model of thought that transcends the dichotomy of order and
disorder, identifying the institutionalization of conflict itself as the ontological
essence of politics—a philosophical project that affirms the possibility of
political creation amidst crisis.
▸Keywords: Roberto Esposito, Machiavelli, Conflict, ‘Pensiero Istituente’,
Biopolitics